Whatever Question and Answer I am posting, all these questions are asked by the SHIYAT (Rafdhiyat).
QUESTION:
Ahl’ul Sunnah have four principles of law the Qur’an, Sunnah, Ijtihad and Qiyas. If one refers to the events of Saqifa, were any of these principles applied?
ANSWER:
A complete confusion. First what the author is TRYING to refer to are principles of Fiqh and not governing a society. And there are more to it like Ijma and also including Ijtihad in the list shows that the author knows nothing about sources of Fiqh in Shia or Sunni discipline. If you read the history of Islam you will see that the holy prophet established a very democratic society in which many of the decisions (of course except those revealed by God) were made through consulting with experienced people. What happened in Saqifah was in fact an approach that was established by the Prophet (SAWW) himself. In this way you might say it was based on Sunnah and ijtehad. On the other hand there are absolutely no clear evidence for the doctrine of having 12 Imams in Quran and Sunnat. So the same question applies to Ithna Ashari themselves?
The question and any replies to it have nothing to do with proving that Ithna Ashari Shia is the right version of Islam.
(I request to all my Muslim brothers, sisters and friends please read, understand, learn this answer and then throw on their faces.)
JAZAKALLAHU KHAIRAN KASEERAN KASEERAH…
Muhammad Raghib Khan
A Slave of ALLAH SWT.
(Muhafiz Azmat-e-Sahaba R.A.A.)
QUESTION:
Ahl’ul Sunnah have four principles of law the Qur’an, Sunnah, Ijtihad and Qiyas. If one refers to the events of Saqifa, were any of these principles applied?
ANSWER:
A complete confusion. First what the author is TRYING to refer to are principles of Fiqh and not governing a society. And there are more to it like Ijma and also including Ijtihad in the list shows that the author knows nothing about sources of Fiqh in Shia or Sunni discipline. If you read the history of Islam you will see that the holy prophet established a very democratic society in which many of the decisions (of course except those revealed by God) were made through consulting with experienced people. What happened in Saqifah was in fact an approach that was established by the Prophet (SAWW) himself. In this way you might say it was based on Sunnah and ijtehad. On the other hand there are absolutely no clear evidence for the doctrine of having 12 Imams in Quran and Sunnat. So the same question applies to Ithna Ashari themselves?
The question and any replies to it have nothing to do with proving that Ithna Ashari Shia is the right version of Islam.
(I request to all my Muslim brothers, sisters and friends please read, understand, learn this answer and then throw on their faces.)
JAZAKALLAHU KHAIRAN KASEERAN KASEERAH…
Muhammad Raghib Khan
A Slave of ALLAH SWT.
(Muhafiz Azmat-e-Sahaba R.A.A.)
No comments:
Post a Comment