ANSWER OF QUESTION ON SADAQA FOR AHLULBAYT (R.A.A.)…
Whatever Question and Answer I am posting, all these questions were asked by the SHIYAT (Rafdhiyat).
QUESTION:
Of the 124,000 Prophets’ that Allah (Swt) sent, what evidence is there that they left everything for their followers as Sadaqah (Charity)? If they did then why did the Prophet (Saaws)’s wives not give all their possessions to the Islamic State? After all, Ahl’ul Sunnah consider the wives to be Ahlulbayt. Sadaqah is haram on the Ahlulbayt, this being the case why did they hold on to their possessions?
ANSWER:
This is again a complete ignorance and the question is totally illogical. If Fatima allegedly had a share in the land of fadak then wouldn’t the wives have a share in it too? Why do shias forget this thing!! If Hadhrat Abu Bakr (R.A.) was unjust in not giving the share of fadak to Hadhrat Fatima (R.A.), he also did not give it to his own daughter Hadhrat Ayesha (R.A.)!! He stated that Prophets (SAWW) do not leave any inheritance to be shared by the inheritors. You can read in Usoole Kafi the hadith were it says that prophets do not leave any heritage. Imam Khomeini in one of his books of Fiqah endorses the correctness of this hadith.
As for the wives of the Prophet (SAWW), you need to read the history to see how the Prophet (SAWW) made each one of them a house of her own, it wasn’t a heritage or a gift. Comparing Fadak (a land captured by Muslims) to the houses of the wives of the Prophet (SAWW) is very funny. As for giving living money to the wives of the Prophet (SAWW), it is very natural thing. They could not be married again and they had no properties, many of them had no proper relatives to rely on. What do you expect them to do for living at that time if you were the Caliph? Begging?! It is narrated in a hadith (in Bukhari) to the effect that some of the wives of the Prophet (SAWW) went to Hadhrat Ayesha (R.A.) in the time of Hadhrat Umar (R.A.) to encourage her accompany them to Hadhrat Umar’s (R.A.) house to ask for heritage from the Prophet (SAWW), Hadhrat Ayesha (R.A.) rejected and said prophets do not leave any heritage, as the result they also changed their mind. The question and any replies to it have nothing to do with proving that 12ers Shia is the right version of Islam.
The question and any replies to it have nothing to do with proving that 12ers Shia is the right version of Islam, nothing else.
(I request to all my Muslim brothers, sisters and friends please read, understand, learn this answer and then throw on their faces.)
JAZAKALLAHU KHAIRAN KASEERAN KASEERAH…
Muhammad Raghib Khan
A Slave of ALLAH SWT.
(Muhafiz Azmat-e-Sahaba R.A.A.)
Whatever Question and Answer I am posting, all these questions were asked by the SHIYAT (Rafdhiyat).
QUESTION:
Of the 124,000 Prophets’ that Allah (Swt) sent, what evidence is there that they left everything for their followers as Sadaqah (Charity)? If they did then why did the Prophet (Saaws)’s wives not give all their possessions to the Islamic State? After all, Ahl’ul Sunnah consider the wives to be Ahlulbayt. Sadaqah is haram on the Ahlulbayt, this being the case why did they hold on to their possessions?
ANSWER:
This is again a complete ignorance and the question is totally illogical. If Fatima allegedly had a share in the land of fadak then wouldn’t the wives have a share in it too? Why do shias forget this thing!! If Hadhrat Abu Bakr (R.A.) was unjust in not giving the share of fadak to Hadhrat Fatima (R.A.), he also did not give it to his own daughter Hadhrat Ayesha (R.A.)!! He stated that Prophets (SAWW) do not leave any inheritance to be shared by the inheritors. You can read in Usoole Kafi the hadith were it says that prophets do not leave any heritage. Imam Khomeini in one of his books of Fiqah endorses the correctness of this hadith.
As for the wives of the Prophet (SAWW), you need to read the history to see how the Prophet (SAWW) made each one of them a house of her own, it wasn’t a heritage or a gift. Comparing Fadak (a land captured by Muslims) to the houses of the wives of the Prophet (SAWW) is very funny. As for giving living money to the wives of the Prophet (SAWW), it is very natural thing. They could not be married again and they had no properties, many of them had no proper relatives to rely on. What do you expect them to do for living at that time if you were the Caliph? Begging?! It is narrated in a hadith (in Bukhari) to the effect that some of the wives of the Prophet (SAWW) went to Hadhrat Ayesha (R.A.) in the time of Hadhrat Umar (R.A.) to encourage her accompany them to Hadhrat Umar’s (R.A.) house to ask for heritage from the Prophet (SAWW), Hadhrat Ayesha (R.A.) rejected and said prophets do not leave any heritage, as the result they also changed their mind. The question and any replies to it have nothing to do with proving that 12ers Shia is the right version of Islam.
The question and any replies to it have nothing to do with proving that 12ers Shia is the right version of Islam, nothing else.
(I request to all my Muslim brothers, sisters and friends please read, understand, learn this answer and then throw on their faces.)
JAZAKALLAHU KHAIRAN KASEERAN KASEERAH…
Muhammad Raghib Khan
A Slave of ALLAH SWT.
(Muhafiz Azmat-e-Sahaba R.A.A.)
No comments:
Post a Comment